What’s Worse - Bad Credit History or No Credit History?

Posted by Tom Magor in Credit Check on 21 June 2018 - Tom is a Senior Credit Analyst at checkmyfile.

Whenever an application for credit is made, a prospective lender is basically looking to ensure (as much as they can) that any money they loan is going to be repaid on time. A key component in their final decision is the applicant's previous history of borrowing and making payments on time. But how does a typical lender view a consumer with little or no credit history, compared to someone with negative information recorded against them?

Of course lenders are often as different and individual as the customers they serve, so while one might be happy to accept someone with a history of chequered payments or a complete blank canvass, another might be very reluctant to lend to either. As lenders never make their criteria known, the only way to find out is by applying, but knowing what is held about you, and how you’re likely to be viewed is vital.

For the best way to find out how you appear to lenders, you can try checkmyfile free for 30 days and then for just £14.99 a month, which you can cancel at any time. It’s the UK’s most detailed credit report, with information from 4 credit reference agencies, not just 1, which lets you see what lenders see.

The issues with having a poor credit history

Having a poor credit history generally means that payments haven’t been made on time in the past. Accounts may be characterised by late payments, arrears and in the more severe cases, defaults . This is when the original credit agreement is considered broken by the lender and the borrower becomes a debtor as opposed to a customer. In serious cases there may be court information present in the form of an insolvency or CCJ .

Getting a loan with a bad credit history

The problem with having negative information recorded on your Credit Report is that most lenders will assume that history will repeat itself and you won’t make repayments on time, ultimately leaving them out-of-pocket. This is a fundamental part of credit scoring and has been proven to be highly accurate in predicting future behaviour.

If there is adverse information on your Credit Report, and depending on the severity, it is likely be harder to get a loan or other forms of finance from certain lenders until it is removed automatically. Where you are able to get credit, it’s likely to come at a much higher APR, to reflect the increased ‘risk’ that the lender is taking.

Negative payment information will remain on your Credit Report for six years from the date that the marker was created, and should then be removed automatically. As long as further adverse information hasn’t been recorded, you may find that lenders are then more willing to accept your application. The exact impact that each entry has on your ability to get credit will vary depending on the other information your Credit Report contains, which is why knowing what is held about you is so important.

The issues with having little credit history

If someone has a limited credit history – usually because they’ve not held credit agreements in the past – it gives prospective lenders very little information on which to base their decision, and in most cases, they will err on the side of caution and decline the application. Whilst there might not be any adverse information to speak of, this sort of applicant is an unknown quantity and therefore more of a risk than someone with a proven record of managing credit.

This is typically the case with young adults but can also be widely seen in other age groups if purchases have always made using cash or from a debit account rather than on credit cards. The same applies where someone has always used a sim-only or Pay As You Go mobile phone rather than a contract one – the former won’t appear on your Credit Report.

Even if you are inherently wealthy, if you haven’t got a history of borrowing, you’re likely to face the same problem.

If you have a limited payment history, while we don’t advise obtaining credit solely for the purpose of increasing your score, it can make a lot of sense to take out a credit card (there are a number of providers that specialise in customers with a limited credit history) and simply use it for every-day purchases before clearing the balance in full each month. As long as repayments are made on time (a Direct Debit is best) then you’ll be able to establish the foundations of a good credit rating relatively quickly, and over time, open up access to wider (and cheaper) forms of borrowing.

Getting a loan with no credit history

If you’re prepared to spend a bit of time working towards it, you can build up the information on your Credit Report well in advance of needing to apply for large forms of borrowing, such as a mortgage.

Even if you haven’t held credit accounts in the past, there is other information contained on your Credit Report that lenders will look at when they assess any application that you need to ensure is correct. Your Electoral Roll listing and any Court Information are both included as ‘public’ elements of your Report, and it’s important that everything is correct.

What they both have in common

What the two situations have in common is that neither of them are permanent: no matter what your circumstances are, with time you can improve your creditworthiness in the eyes of a lender. If you have no previous credit agreements and are starting from scratch, by taking out a simple credit card and making all payments on time you will find your credit rating soon begins to improve.

If there are negative markers on your credit report (such as missed payments or defaults), these will only appear on your Credit Report for six years from the date they were issued and so once this time is up lenders will no longer see them. Additionally, the impact of negative information lessens over time for many lenders, which means even before the information has dropped off, you might find more lenders are willing to extend you credit.

Similarly, specialist products aimed at people with either a less-than-perfect or very limited credit history are both likely to come at a much higher rate of interest – the best deals are reserved for people with a strong credit rating.

How to make the most of either situation

Regardless of whether you’ve got a poor credit history or you’ve never taken out a loan in your life, before you apply for anything it’s important to check your Credit Report yourself so that you know exactly where you stand.

Without checking, there’s no way of knowing whether the information on your Report is correct, or what a typical lender will be using to assess your application.

If you haven’t already, you can try checkmyfile free for 30 days and then for just £14.99 a month afterwards, which you can cancel at any time.

Could Your Voice Pass a Credit Check?

Speech recognition has come a long way in a relatively short period of time and is now a fairly accepted part of everyday life.

Published on 23 May 2019 by Richard Catlin

Full Article

The Reason Why Employers Carry Out Credit Checks

Credit checks are commonplace in the UK these days, playing a major role in events such as applying for a mortgage, car finance and renting a property to name just a few. Less commonly known is that sometimes even a new job can require that you pass a credit check as part of the selection criteria.

Published on 1 Apr 2019 by Sam Griffin

Full Article

Why Insurance Quotes Use Credit Checks

When you go online to get an insurance quote (be it home, car or most other products that involve a monthly premium) you may unknowingly be only a few clicks away from undergoing a credit check. Very often you won’t even see a specific notification before it happens unless you read through the company’s terms and conditions in their entirety.

Published on 8 Mar 2019 by Jamie Mackenzie Smith

Full Article

Can I Rent With Bad Credit?

The outcome of the credit checks carried out by landlords or letting agents is a pivotal moment in the application process when you go to rent a property, but the actual information they will be looking at is probably a lot less daunting than you might expect.

Published on 14 Aug 2018 by Jamie Mackenzie Smith

Full Article

What Landlords, Employers and Lenders See on Your Credit Report

Your credit report is likely to be viewed many times during your life - often at key moments. While you might expect this when you’re about to apply for a mortgage or a car loan, it may also be checked by a prospective landlord or employer, and just like lenders, there are some key pieces of information they’re looking for that can make or break your job application or property rental.

Published on 29 Jan 2018 by Sam Griffin

Full Article

How lenders can change your interest rate even after an account has been opened

Most people are aware that your credit report and rating have a heavy bearing on whether a lender accepts or declines an application, and the rate of interest that comes with the account. However, not everyone knows that credit scoring – in the form of a particular lenders’ appetite for ‘risk’ - can continue to have an impact on your account even after it has been opened.

Published on 24 Jan 2018 by Kiah Phillips

Full Article

6 Things Lenders Don’t Want to See on Your Credit File

We live in a time where credit ratings have an ever-increasing impact on our lives. Mortgages, loans, car finance, phone contracts… almost anything that involves a degree of borrowing is likely to involve your credit report, or rather, the information it contains. A lot of information goes under the microscope during an application and unless you know exactly what you’re looking at, you may not realise which elements could be hurting your rating the most.

Published on 5 Jan 2018 by Beth Jennings

Full Article

No credit is good credit. Think again

Picture this scenario. You go into a mobile phone shop to get the latest release on a contract. At £30 a month, it is well within your affordability, without pushing your monthly income too much. All in hand, you may think.

Published on 4 Apr 2016 by Ben Tumilty

Full Article

How to go all 007 and get yourself an Aston Martin

Spectre, the 24th Bond film, is released in November and is sure to feature a string of vehicles that will have cinema goers gazing longingly.

Published on 17 Sep 2015 by Richard Catlin

Full Article

When information on your credit report is wrong

One of the main benefits of keeping track of your credit file is that you are able to monitor how your accounts are being reported to future lenders. Whether the account information is correct or not, lenders are increasingly relying solely on computers to interpret your credit file and when there is incorrect information, consumers face the potential of being declined for everyone’s least favourite reason – computer says ‘no’.

Published on 17 Nov 2014 by George Coburn

Full Article


We are rated number 1 for customer service on