Are unsecured debts really 'unsecured'?
Posted in 'Dealing with Debt' by Barry Stamp
12 December 2011
It's one year on since we reported that the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) reacted strongly to the growing trend of lenders forcing consumers to sell their homes in order to pay fairly small unsecured debts. But not much seems to have come from this.
According the the quarterly statistics published by the Ministry of Justice, the average number of charging orders per quarter in 2011 is 22,747 - not that much removed from the 2010 average of 23,405.
Four lenders - Alliance & Leicester, HFC Bank, American Express and Welcome Finance - were singled out for criticism of their use of charging orders and told to change their business practices.
Many people believe that ‘unsecured’ forms of borrowing – such as personal loans and credit cards – mean that if the worst comes to the worst and they are no longer able to keep up with repayments, then any property they own is safe from possession.
This isn’t always the case.
If attempts to obtain repayment of debt following the granting of a county court judgment are unsuccessful, lenders can then apply to the court for something called a charging order over any specific property owned by the debtor. This could include a house, land, or even stocks and shares.
A charging order does not give the lender the right to force a sale of a property. Lenders who have charging orders can simply sit back and wait for when the property is sold, and then get repayment, and interest, from the net sale proceeds. The debts already secured against the property, before the court granted the charging order, such as a mortgage, are taken first.
The number of charging orders granted in the UK has soared in recent years, rising from 45,000 in 2005 to around 165,000 this year. Lenders with a charging order are able to apply to the courts to force the sale of a property, but this is rarely sought in practice.
Charging orders are not a new concept, and the OFT acknowledges that lenders are entitled by law to use them, but following its investigation, has warned them that they must be used proportionately to the situation.
The OFT found that the four banks named fell short in a number of areas, including not taking into account individual circumstances, in respect of the level of charges added to accounts, and in some cases using misleading correspondence. In some cases, charging orders were applied for in relation to debts of just £600.
All four companies named in the report cooperated fully and have since made changes to the areas of their business that drew criticism.
If you are struggling with debts – big or small, secured or unsecured – and need some help, you can get free, impartial information in our Debt Advice Centre.
We'll be keeping an eye on the trend of Charging Orders. We're hoping that the OFT will be too.
Barry is a Chartered Banker and a Fellow of the Institute of Credit Management. He has a degree in Statistics and Business Economics from the Open University. Barry writes mostly on news from the worlds of banking and mortgages.
Barry Stamp is a co-founder of checkmyfile.
The debt charity, StepChange, has seen a surge of people asking for help with council tax arrears in the past year, with their recent survey showing a 77% increase.
In 2012 StepChange helped 25,500 people in arrears, a number that has risen to 45,561 in 2013, with the average person £102 short of the money needed to pay their bill.
StepChange's chief executive, Mike O'Connor was quick to explain where he thinks the blame lies. "Stagnating incomes, changing work patterns, rising living costs and changes in welfare benefits are a toxic combination" he said. The analysts behind the survey also believe the government Council Tax Benefit reforms of April 2013 to be a contributing factor.
The government implemented those ch .....
The Low Commission, headed by Lord Low has recommended a levy be placed on payday lenders to fund debt advisory services.
The commission, an independent enquiry into the effects of cuts in legal aid on social welfare, heard from one MP witness that consumers were using MP's surgeries to try and get legal advice, after the last round of legal aid cuts made seeking professional advice more expensive. Andy Slaughter, the shadow justice minister claimed: “Major advice agencies like Shelter and CAB [Citizens Advice Bureau] are able to answer less than half of the vastly increased numbers of inquiries from people in desperate need.”
A key recommendation is for a £100m annual fund for local advice centres across England and Wales. M .....
Well, the top five are, and 21 of the worst 50 are. So maybe it's not quite so nice to be beside the seaside after all.