Why those with high credit scores might get rejected

Posted by Ben Ryland in Credit Reports on 5 December 2016 - Ben is a Senior Credit Analyst at checkmyfile.

Does an excellent credit score mean you will always get the credit you apply for? Well, no it doesn’t.

When an application is made for credit, the checking of your credit file and credit score is only part of the whole credit underwriting process. So even if you have a very high credit score, this won’t automatically result in the application for credit being accepted.

So what are some of the most common reasons why an application is declined if you have a high credit score?

Number 1 is that you may have insufficient income.

Credit files do not detail your income or your job, and they do not suggest to a potential lender how much money you make. A credit report focuses on how you manage your credit agreements - do you make your payments on time, are you late with some and are others left unpaid? This helps a lender to determine the risk of the credit borrowed not being repaid. But for those with excellent credit scores who have no negative payment history, the application could be declined on the basis of income.

For example, take an applicant who has three credit cards, with a total of £10,000 outstanding across the cards. They make repayments to all three each month and the balances are not near the credit limits. This applicant would appear to be low risk and the credit score would reflect the regular payments being made each month. But while the credit score might be high, if the applicant’s annual income was £20,000, the credit card debt equates to half of the annual income. This could put pressure on the applicant’s monthly commitments if further credit was granted and so the income plays a significant part in the decision-making process.

A credit score above 750 is considered an above average credit score, but if your score is good you may be declined if you have not been credit active enough in recent times. If you have been repaying your credit agreements on time for the last 12 months but have no history prior to that, you may see your applications declined if the lender wants to see a longer period of positive repayments, even if your score is above 750.

Finally, there is no universal credit score which is used by lenders and credit reference agencies, and each score will be different. The score that is generated for you by a credit agency will give you an indication of your overall credit profile. Each lender will also have their own criteria when assessing your application and are unlikely to use your agency generated score. Instead, they will compare your file date to their decision matrix and if you don’t meet enough requirements this can cause an application to be declined, even if your credit score is high. As mentioned above this could be the income criteria which isn’t high enough even if your score is favourable.

A lending decision is always at the discretion of the credit provider and if the credit score is high but an application has been declined it is likely the reason is non-credit file related. Just remember, credit is never a given and no one is simply entitled to credit from a lender.

Check Your Multi-Agency Credit Report

30 Day Free Trial

How often should you check your Credit Report

Your Credit Report is a key component in lots of important life events. What it says about you could make or break a credit application and so it’s vital that you know for yourself what’s being reported.

Published on 2 Jul 2019 by Richard Catlin

Full Article

The Advantages of a Multi-Agency Credit Report

These days your Credit Report can be checked for any number of reasons throughout the year, including background checks during job applications, landlord checks and even from insurance or utility providers when you shop around for quotes.

Published on 17 May 2019 by Paul Anderson Riley

Full Article

What Lenders Want To See On Your Credit Report

Your Credit Report holds a huge amount of information about you and your past relationship with credit. It’s collated from a wide variety of sources, is always changing and plays a major part in any lending decision - but you shouldn’t be afraid of what it shows.

Published on 2 May 2019 by Sam Griffin

Full Article

What Credit Searches Mean

One of the most commonly misunderstood aspects of Credit Reports are the credit Search Footprints left on your report whenever someone accesses your file.

Published on 25 Apr 2019 by Kirstie Day

Full Article

How to dispute an account error on your report

Whether you’ve been turned down for credit in the past and have checked your Credit Report to make sure there’s nothing there harming your chances, you’re checking ahead of making an application, or you’re just looking to make sure everything is as it should be, there’s never a good time to find a mistake with the information on your report.

Published on 17 Apr 2019 by Kelly Luff

Full Article

Your Rights When Cancelling a New Credit Agreement

For most people applying for credit the main concern is whether or not they will be actually get accepted. But occasionally a change in circumstances (or even just a little time to reflect on your purchase) means that a bigger concern might be whether you can change your mind and withdraw from a credit agreement (be it a credit card, personal loan or other credit facility) after it’s been granted, potentially preventing you from taking on additional financial responsibility that you no longer want or need.

Published on 18 Mar 2019 by Tom Magor

Full Article

Creditworthiness and Affordability – Which is Which

When reading the small print on most applications for credit, you’ve probably noticed two words regularly popping up: Creditworthiness and Affordability. Both of these measures are used by a vast majority of lenders when assessing your application, so understanding what each one means goes a long way to explaining why you may or may not be accepted for credit.

Published on 22 Feb 2019 by Ben Tumilty

Full Article

What Information Is On My Credit Report?

If you’ve ever taken out a loan, credit card, or other form of finance, you’ll know that the difference between acceptance and rejection relies heavily on the outcome of what the lender finds when it checks your Credit Report.

Published on 4 Jan 2019 by Paul Anderson-Riley

Full Article

Can Right to Erasure Get Rid of Bad Credit History?

General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR for short) was introduced on 25 May 2018 and unless you’ve managed to avoid the internet and checking your emails completely for the past year, you’re likely to have been bombarded with messages from nervous sounding websites updating their data policies.

Published on 3 Jan 2019 by Jamie Mackenzie Smith

Full Article

Why Searches Can’t Be Removed From Your Credit Report

The Searches section of your Credit Report shows you who has accessed the information on your Credit Report within the last couple of years. This effectively acts as a log of when you’ve checked your own Report, as well as a record of lenders checking as a result of applications for credit in your name. You’re also likely to see searches relating to prospective employers, landlords, insurance companies and other identity checks.

Published on 2 Jan 2019 by Beth Jennings

Full Article


We are rated number 1 for customer service on